Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde | The difference between overt and covert narcissists

“All human beings, as we meet them, are commingled out of good and evil: and Edward Hyde, alone, in the ranks of mankind, was pure evil.” ― Robert Louis Stevenson, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde
 
When the Scottish author Robert Lou Stevenson published his novel "Strange case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde" in 1886 he probably did not even realize how amazing job he did with analysis of the narcissistic personality disorder. His novel is a journey into a mind of a narcissist whose mind is like a moon in a waning crescent phase - the narcissist will only let you see the little fraction of his psyche just like the moon will allow you to see only this little part that is illumined with the sun rays. The rest of the moon is well hidden in the darkness together with its secrets giving you this fake impression that there is nothing else to see. Just like the Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, the narcissists are capable to switch between overt and covert modes.

What is the main difference between the overt and covert narcissists?

All narcissists, no matter what type they are, were once the victims of the narcissistic abuse in their childhood. This is how they developed their personality disorder. You do not become a pathological narcissist without being traumatized first. A lot of them do not suffer only from narcissism but also from PTSD and C-PTSD.

The overt narcissists are individuals who are expressing their aggressiveness and grandiosity openly. They are very cocky, arrogant, extroverted, they are open bullies, they have tendencies to scream loudly, name call the people, physically attack others. They are known for direct abuse. They create a false illusion of a confidence to mask their real emotions developed in their childhood of feeling not lovable, not good enough, not worthy and feeling inadequate. They try to over - achieve their goals to outmatch others ("If they did this, I will do even more! If they are good, I will be better!"). This urgent need to be the best at all costs and feeling emotionally injured when someone else is shinning more than them is their trauma acting out. They are the narcissistic supply junkies and they are trying to get their needs met as their needs have not been met in their childhood. Often, they damage other people in the process. They do not have any personal reason to hurt others. They are acting their trauma out and they project their disorder on every person they meet (it does not matter who the person is). They carry the wound "I am not good enough" from their childhood thus they have the urge "to be more" than others in their adulthood. They carry the wound "I am not lovable" from their childhood thus they have the urge to wear a "false self masks" to be loved by others. They feel that if they do not wear the masks, they would be unlovable. They are following their goals with an openly aggressive approach and they are very ambitious. They are exhibitionists and they are constantly seeking an attention at all costs. In most of the cases they get that attention and they do not have an issue to gain the narcissistic supply for themselves thanks to their open grandiosity. They brag a lot about who they know, what they own and how awesome they think they are. They present themselves as "special" by telling people: "Look at me, look at me, I am special!". They are very visibly and openly self-absorbed and self entitled. They have an illusion of grandiosity. The background of their childhood is in most cases more physically violent than the childhood of the covert narcissists. They have been often physically attacked and physically abused by their caregiver(s).

Both types of the narcissists share the same traits, they only manifest them in a different way and the result of their narcissistic abuse is the same for their victims. The "overts" and "coverts" are "brothers from one mother". While overt narcissists abuse people in a direct way, the covert narcissists use more sneaky and indirect way how to abuse people. 

The covert type of the narcissists (also known as vulnerable narcissists or introverted narcissists or shy narcissists) are disordered individuals who secretly wish to be like the overt narcissists but they are not capable of being that way because their super ego (the inner critical voice in their head of their caregivers telling them they are not good enough) are attacking their grandiosity. Their super ego is crippling their grandiosity. This prevent their grandiosity to go full blown and open. The covert narcissists are failed overt narcissists. As they do not posses such qualities like the overt narcissists, they have to come up with much sneakier tactics to obtain the narcissistic supply. They need to invest more time and more effort to gain at least the fraction of the narcissistic supply in comparison with the "overts". The covert narcissists have to become more calculative and more methodical in choosing the targets and proceeding with an abuse. They have a lot of anxieties, insecurities, complexes and a very low self-esteem. They constantly worry. The "coverts" are more introverted and non social. They are non assertive, not capable and they carry a very impotent energy. The open grandiosity would make the "coverts" very vulnerable and they are secretly scared that people would notice how fake they are and that their "false self mask" would be uncovered so they rather choose a different tactics to obtain narcissistic supply - they pretend to be overly nice, overly polite , they act likeable, over  - helpful, over - friendly and they always please others rather than being openly aggressive. They wear a fake masks of a caring people convincing others around them about their kindness with cognitive empathy (learned fake empathy). They are wolves in the sheep clothing. They express their grandiosity with doing charity, pretending to be heroes and  martyrs, they exhibit messiah complex and they are forever "victims". They have overly pathetic personality. As they are not capable to gain an admiration the way like the "overts" do, they at least manipulate the people´s emotions to gain sympathy with never ending pity party and victim´s mentality. They are masters of guilt tripping, gas lighting, extreme subliminal manipulation, triangulation, passive aggressiveness, exaggerating their imaginary sufferings (which they in most cases inflicted on themselves with their self destructive nature) and they operate solely behind the scene. They are wonderful sad sob story tellers and they use the sad sob stories to gain the sympathy from the victims. They subliminally force the victims to feel sorry for them all the time. They are extremely draining people to be around and that´s why they are known as "emotional vampires". They often stage crisis to gain attention and to gain a control over others. While the "overts" prefer to achieve their goals by themselves thanks to their aggressive nature, the "coverts" prefer to live a lifestyle of parasitism on others. They always need someone to come and save them. The covert narcissists are more introverted and they do not like to be a center of an attention, rather they ally with exhibitionist personalities and dominant people and they gain the narcissistic supply through the association with more powerful, rich, famous, overtly abusive and extroverted people. Many people (not all of them but many) with disordered unhealthy codependent attachments style such the covert narcissists, codependents, borderlines and histrionic people are often destined to end up in the relationships with overt narcissists due to fatal attraction and they become an easy target and a quick meal for this dominant predators. Its exactly their codependency which automatically attracts them to the dominant and aggressive individuals. The "coverts" have an illusion of grandiosity. They feel angry and they receive a narcissistic emotional injury when the world does not recognize their awesomeness. They feel entitlement and they feel special just like the overt narcissists, they just manifest their disillusion in a different way - they do not openly praise themselves but instead of telling people directly how special they are, they force and manipulate others to praise them (for example they give people the fake over exaggerated compliments and they force others in a very uncomfortable hidden way to pay them the flattery back. Once they receive the compliments back, they fake the modesty). Or they minimize their own beauty, skills, talents, accomplishments so people would offer them reassurance on how beautiful, skilled, talented they are. They need others to constantly feed them with reassurance to boost their self-importance. Al thought, they hide their grandiosity well due to their fearful and anxious nature, they have idealized version of themselves and they desperately need others to sustain them. They need nonstop emotional support from their narcissistic supply sources, otherwise they emotionally collapse and become depressed. They hide their grandiosity behind the fake modesty. Oftentimes, the covert narcissists are pillar of the community, they do a lot of charity things, they overly serve others and they overly please others. There is nothing worse than owning a covert narcissists the favors as they often use all good doings they did for others as the weapon for guilt tripping. They help others to receive recognition and validation as the covert narcissists are not capable to validate themselves and they solely rely on the validation from external sources. While the overt narcissists present themselves as special ("Look at me, I am special!"), the covert narcissists feel special by making other people special. They always pull the "poor me card" and they need other people´s support to feel special. They make others feel special during the love bombing and idealization phase and once the victims enter the discard phase, the covert narcissists will punish them for making them work hard to make them feel special. They love to give the gifts to others as a manipulation to create the bond with them and later on they use this bond for guilt tripping the victims. They force the victims to let the covert narcissists invest in them (and they usually invest low quality, broken items, old stuff, food after expiration date) and in the end they guilt trip the victims to return them the favor 5 times fold (high quality -  expensive items, new stuff, expensive meals at the restaurant). They are giving the gifts and money to the victims to create the bond and then use this bond to emotionally and psychologically abuse them ("I payed 5 dollars for your cell phone bill, so I can do everything I want with you, even give you a call in 2 AM and you have to pick the phone up every time I call you, even if I call you 50 times a day when I try to control you and you will talk to me one hour on the phone even you are at work! You owe me 5 dollars so I have the right to guilt trip you to become my servant and clean my house 20 times!). The narcissists invest 1 dollar in the victims during the love bombing stage and then they make sure they will get their investment back, they will get back from the victims at least 20 dollars. The brain of the narcissists are wired in a similar way like the brain of the psychopaths - they are motivated by rewards. They never to anything for anybody without an agenda.

While the overt narcissists suffer more from the avoidant attachment style (as they are heading more to the sociopathic and psychopathic side of the scale of empathy and consciousness), the covert narcissists suffer more from the anxious hyper-activated codependent attachment style (as they are heading more to the borderline side of the scale of empathy and consciousness). The covert narcissist, in fact, is a very codependent type of a personality. The core of their disorder is an addiction on people. People are their drug and just like the heroin addict is addicted on heroin, the covert narcissists need their "fix" through people. People regulate their emotions and people are their only source of narcissistic supply and their whole inner world depend on the quality and quantity of the emotional support and validation that people gives them. As the covert narcissists tend to be more codependent and their grandiosity is crippled and impotent (in comparison with overt narcissists), they often have depression episodes as they are not capable to "feed" them with narcissistic supply that efficiently as "overts". The "overts" are social butterflies who are not crippled that much with piles of anxiety, they do not suffer from deficit of people around them and the narcissistic supply and their grandiosity (even the self - image is distorted) is functioning more smoothly. The "overts" are high functioning narcissists while the "coverts" are low functioning narcissists.

While the childhood of the overt narcissists have been more physically violent, the covert narcissists are coming from the shame based households where everything looked perfect on the surface, everything was taboo, the elephant in the room was being ignored and in most of the cases there was no physical violence present. While the overt narcissists went most likely through the physical abuse, the "coverts" suffered under the strict parenting style of dominant caregiver(s). The covert narcissists went more through the emotional and psychological abuse rather the physical abuse in their childhood. Their families were filled with shame, they have been often humiliated by the narcissistic parents and their enablers.

The overt narcissists have more tendency to physically attack their victims while the covert narcissists will abuse their victims without even putting the hands on them. However, it does not make the abuse any less abusive. Quite contrary. Their abuse reminds of the killing curse of Voldemort from movie Harry Potter. Once they curse you, you will be writhe in pain you never experienced before. The covert narcissists are the emotional and psychological bullies.

The childhood always plays a great role in an emotional and psychological development of people and usually when you want to understand the root of any personality disorder, one of the best ways to do so is to investigate the childhood of the disordered person. The apple never fall far from the tree. The seed of the disorder and a toxic programming of people is always being planted inside of them in their childhood. We humans are sponges soaking the programming from our environment. Especially in the childhood. The "family karma" or "generation curse" is nothing else than passing the trauma and a dysfunctional programming from one generation to another.

All narcissists (no matter what type,) are addicted to flattery and allergic to shame and criticism. They all have superior complex and they feel they are entitled to special treatment. While the overt narcissists are openly arrogant, the covert narcissists manifest the arrogance in a hidden way. The narcissists wear the "false self mask" and the image and appearance are the most important thing for them. They consider the threat everybody who would be capable to uncover them and remove their mask. While the "overts" have the tendency to abuse the victims openly and even in public, the "coverts" abuse their victims behind the door and in a secret. The covert narcissists rarely scream or physically abuse the victims (except during the grand final discard, then they are capable even murder the victims - for example the case of a covert narcissist Chris Watts). The "overts" operate more in the victim´s face and the "coverts" operate more behind the victim´s back. While it is pretty easy to spot the overt narcissists, it takes time to uncover the covert narcissists. You need to spend a time with the "coverts" to see the mask slip off or at least to see through the cracks in the masks here and there. If you do not know what you are looking for due to the lack of knowledge on narcissism, you can easily overlook the red flags even for decades.

Sign up for NEWSLETTER and receive all my new free blog articles directly to your e-mail.

If you found this article useful, share it with your dear ones who can benefit from this information. I appreciate it. If you wish to support my work, you might consider A DONATION. Thank you for your support. Ready to change your life? BUY MY BOOKS on narcissism and codependency.

“If he be Mr. Hyde" he had thought, "I shall be Mr. Seek.” 
  ― Robert Louis Stevenson, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde 

“If I am the chief of sinners, I am the chief of sufferers also.”
  ― Robert Louis Stevenson, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde 

“You must suffer me to go my own dark way.”  
Robert Louis Stevenson, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde 

“O my poor old Harry Jekyll, if ever I read Satan's signature upon a face, it is on that of your new friend.”
Robert Louis Stevenson, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde 

“Good and evil are so close as to be chained together in the soul.”
Robert Louis Stevenson, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde 

“That child of Hell had nothing human; nothing lived in him but fear and hatred.”
Robert Louis Stevenson, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde